5. At the micro level, the less strong banks, which suffered
capital erosion due to rising levels of non-performing assets were recapitalised.
Secondly, capital to risk-weighted assets ratio of 8 percent was
introduced. This is now at 9 percent. Thirdly, prudential norms
for income recognition, classification of assets and provisioning for bad debts
were introduced. The management of NPAs has been fortified by the enactment
of the Securitisation & Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement
of Securities Interest (SARFAESI) Act, 2002 which provides statutory support
for the enforcement of creditors’ rights and inter alia, paved the way for the
establishment of Asset Reconstruction Companies. Fourthly, Debt Recovery Tribunals
were set up to assist the banks in the recovery of loans. Fifthly, the Scheme
of Ombudsman was introduced in 1995, to look into and resolve customer grievances.
Sixthly, the State Bank of India Act, 1955 and the Bank Nationalisation Act
of 1970 were amended to enable the banks to access the capital market for debt
and equity. Lastly, reforms were also introduced in respect of Regional Rural
Banks (RRBs) and non-bank finance companies (NBFCs).
6. The above measures together with the strengthening of
prudential norms and market discipline and the adoption of international benchmarks
to suit India specific needs have served to make the Indian financial sector
competitive, viable and resilient.
7. Financial crises the world over have revealed that weak
financial systems and their supervision are the most important factors contributing
to macro instability. As East Asia discovered so painfully, the health of the
banking system underpins that of the economy as a whole. Financial markets are
different from product markets and therefore, greater liberalisation goes along
with deeper supervision and higher degree of regulation. Any destablisation
in financial markets affects even those who are not in financial markets. On
the other hand, financial markets can drive the real economy. Therefore, transparency,
disclosures, prudential norms and capitalisation are a must. This is essential
because bank depositors have no other security except that banks are well regulated.
8. Increasing deregulation and globalisation, greater competition
from within the country and cross-border dealings have exposed banks to even
greater risk. Diversification into non-traditional products like insurance,
derivatives etc., has added to the complexity of banking business. Further,
internet banking, e-commerce, e-money and other information technology related
innovations are adding new dimensions to risks faced by the banking sector.
Mergers and acquisitions as well as outsourcing of some non-core activities
are undertaken by the banks with some strategic objectives – they also enhance
the risks in banking. Considering the speed with which banking is changing,
it is recognised that there is a need to enlarge the focus and thrust of Risk-Based
Supervision (RBS) so as to be able to improve the risk sensitivity of the supervisory
approach.
9 In view of the relevance of improved risk management systems
under the changing circumstances and the larger emphasis placed on risk management
systems in banks under Basel II, it is essential that RBS stabilises at an early
date and serves as an important feedback to not only the managements but also
the supervisors. However, taking into account the diversity in the Indian banking
system, stabilising the RBS as an effective supervisory mechanism will be a
daunting task.
Consolidation and Move towards Universal Banking
10. We are slowly but surely moving from a regime of "large
number of small banks" to "small number of large banks". The
new era is going to be one of consolidation around identified core competencies.
Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector are going to be the order of
the day. Successful merger of HDFC Bank and Times Bank earlier and Stanchart
and ANZ Grindlays has demonstrated that the trend towards consolidation is almost
an accepted fact. We are also looking for such signs in respect of a number
of old private sector banks, many of which are not able to cushion their NPAs,
expand their business and induct technology due to limited capital base.
11. Coming times may usher in large banking institutions,
if the development financial institutions opt for conversion into commercial
banking in line with the recommendation of the Second Report of the Narsimhan
Committee. In India, one of the largest financial institutions, ICICI, took
the lead towards universal banking with its reverse merger with ICICI Bank.
IDBI is also well on its way to transform itself into a universal bank. This
may lead logically to promoting the concept of financial super market chain,
making available all types of credit and non-funded facilities under one roof
or specialised subsidiaries under one umbrella organisation. The setting up
of banks by financial institutions and non-banking financial companies and setting
up of insurance, merchant banking, mutual funds, housing finance and investment
companies either as subsidiaries or as joint ventures has brought into focus
the need for consolidated supervision. Consolidated accounting and supervisory
techniques would have to evolve and appropriate firewalls need to be built to
address the risks underlying such large organisations and banking conglomerates.
Supervision/Regulation of Financial Conglomerates
12. The financial landscape is increasingly witnessing entry
of some of the bigger banks into other financial segments like merchant banking,
insurance etc., which has made them financial conglomerates. Emergence of several
new players with diversified presence across major segments and possibility
of some of the non-banking institutions in the financial sector acquiring large
enough proportions to have systemic impact make it imperative for supervision
to be spread across various segments of the financial sector. In this direction,
an inter-regulatory Working Group was constituted with members from RBI, SEBI
and IRDA. The framework proposed by the Group will be complementary to the existing
regulatory structure wherein the individual entities are regulated by the respective
regulators and the identified financial conglomerates would be subjected to
focused regulatory oversight through a mechanism of inter-regulatory exchange
of information.
Risk Management and Capital Adequacy
13. Financial sector reforms in the current millennium are
going to focus on setting the rules of the game for financial intermediaries
in such a way that risks are taken with an adequate level of capital. In other
words, financial intermediaries should be free to engage in asset liability
management that allows them to diversify their risk so long as they are supported
by a level of capital sufficient to cushion them against their risk profile.
14. The first Capital Accord of 1988 evolved by Basel Committee
provided a framework for a fair and reasonable degree of consistency in the
application of capital standards. However, the methods used to determine the
capital charge for credit risk in the accord were not sufficiently sophisticated
and not perceived to be risk sensitive. Keeping in view the financial innovation
and growing complexity of financial transactions, a need was felt for a more
broad based and flexible framework for capital adequacy. Towards this end the
Basel Committee has formulated a new framework, popularly called "Basel
II" which attempts to formulate more precisely than before the levels of
regulatory capital that banks must hold as a cushion against the credit and
other risks that banks take.
Cross-border Supervision
15. This would involve a greater focus on overseas operations
of Indian banks and in having information sharing arrangements with overseas
supervisors on a firmer and more formal footing. In the context of money laundering
concerns raised by some of the supervisors, it needs to be ensured that some
of the branches, especially those which are not compliant with the anti-money
laundering principles of the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), are not causes
of serious operational and reputational risks to their parent banks in India.
Money Laundering
16. Although I touched upon this issue in brief earlier
while discussing cross border supervision, I would like to dwell a little bit
more on this issue as it has been engaging the attention of governments, regulators
and international financial community for quite some time. And there will be
no exaggeration if I call it the biggest challenge before the supervisors today.
17. Post September 11, the issue that bank supervisors the
world over are grappling with is "How to root out the menace of money laundering?"
Until recently, the governments talked tough about the problem, but did little
about it. All that changed three years ago. The FATF was conceived by G-7 countries
as a helpful mechanism to persuade governments to combat money laundering and
offer them technical assistance to do so. The laws being enacted typically require
a bank to "know the customer" to be confident that his money is obtained
by legitimate means, and to report any suspicious activity. This involves a
Herculean effort, thanks in part, to the growth of "Correspondent banking
relationships." In effect, this means banks must know their customers’
customers as well.
18. Banking supervision all over the world has to achieve
the delicate balance between respect for customer privacy and making banks report
suspicious transactions. This raised the toughest question: What exactly are
efforts against money laundering trying to achieve? So far, countries have been
free to define what they regard as illegal sources of money. Some include drugs,
racketeering and other dark crimes in their definition of illegal money. Some,
such as France, consider tax evasion to be money laundering. Others like Switzerland
have more flexible laws. However, as recently as last week, Switzerland has
agreed in principle to dismantle the veil of secrecy governing its banking activity
in order to comply with anti-money laundering requirements. This is a landmark
development.
Corporate Governance
19. I would also like to touch upon an area, which is going
to be the focus of the next generation financial sector reforms. One of the
latest initiatives of RBI aims at enhancing the level of corporate governance
in banks.
20. In view of the special status enjoyed by banks whereby
they freely accept deposits from the public and leverage on such funds through
credit creation, legal prescription for ownership and governance of banks have
been laid down in the Banking Regulation Act, 1949. These have been supplemented
by regulatory prescriptions issued by the Reserve Bank from time to time. These
cover the following aspects:
- Composition of the Board of Directors
- Approval of the Reserve bank for the appointment of CEO
- Powers for the removal of managerial personnel, CEO and Directors
- Guidelines on criteria for appointment, role and responsibilities of Directors
- Guidelines for acknowledgement of transfer/allotment of shares in private
sector banks
- Foreign investment in the banking sector
We have recently placed in public domain a draft paper on ‘A
comprehensive policy framework for ownership and governance in private sector
banks’. The objective of the draft guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank in
July 2004 is to have a regulatory road map for ownership and governance in private
sector banks in the interests of the depositors and financial stability. The
underlying thread of the draft guidelines is to ensure that the ultimate ownership
and control of banks is well diversified, banks are owned and managed by ‘fit
and proper’ persons/entities and well capitalised and that the processes are
transparent and fair. Several countries, both developed and developing, have
regulatory stipulations and clearance for significant shareholding and control.
The threshold level may vary from country to country and can also involve more
stringent conditions for higher thresholds.
21. The draft guidelines allow for a level of shareholding
of a single entity or a group of related entities beyond 10 per cent with the
prior approval of the Reserve Bank. Such approval will be governed by the principles
enunciated in the February 2004 guidelines. Apart from more intensive due diligence
at higher levels of shareholding, the February 2004 guidelines require public
interest objectives to be served for shareholding beyond 30 percent. In case
where the ownership of a bank is that by a corporate entity, diversified ownership
of that corporate entity will be considered among other factors. The draft guidelines
do not cover foreign bank investment in Indian banks, which will be released
separately consistent with the policy in the Government press note of March
2004 to allow only one form of operational presence for foreign banks in India.
22. In order to minimise vulnerability due to small size,
the guidelines provide for increase in the net owned funds to Rs.300 crore for
all private sector banks within a reasonable period. Cross holding beyond five
percent is sought to be discouraged and where such holding exceeds five percent,
the objective is to reduce it to five percent. Promoters with existing shareholding
beyond ten percent will be required to indicate the time table for reduction
– the requests will be considered on the basis of the underlying principles
of ‘fit and proper’, governance and public interest. As a matter of desirable
practice, not more than one member of a family or close relative or associate
should be on the board. Based on the feedback received, a second draft of the
guidelines would be prepared and put in public domain. The broad principles
underlying the proposed framework is intended to ensure the following:
- Well-diversified ownership and control
- ‘fit and proper’ status of important shareholders, Directors and CEO
- Minimum capital/net worth for optimal operations and systemic stability
- Transparency and fairness of policy and process.
23. A consultative group headed by Dr. Ashok Ganguli was
set up to review the supervisory role of board of banks. The recommendations
included due diligence procedures for appointment of directors, the role and
responsibilities of independent non-executive directors, qualification and other
eligibility criteria for appointment of non-executive directors, providing training
to the non-executive directors so that they are in touch with the latest developments,
etc.
24. In the midst of all these initiatives and challenges,
a major challenge for the Reserve Bank has been to ensure that the overarching
banking regulatory framework facilitates banking services reaching the common
man. The Reserve Bank has appointed an External Committee on Procedures and
Performance Audit on Public Services headed by Dr. S.S. Tarapore and this committee
has in one of its reports focused on depositor’s accounts and other banking
facilities relating to individuals – the common man. Subsequently, Governor,
Dr. Y.V. Reddy has addressed all the Chairmen of banks reminding them of the
trust reposed by the common person in the nature and quality of customer service
rendered by banks. Banks must recognise that if there is disenfranchisement
of the depositor they may wake up to find slippages on the liability side of
their balance sheet.
25. In the ultimate analysis, however, it is the human resource
which will have to respond to these challenges and in the words of our previous
Governor, Dr. Bimal Jalan, "In the years to come this ‘human’ bias is likely
to get stronger and the quality of human resources would become the cutting
edge of competitiveness. A forward looking approach to our long term vision
must focus on building human resources in a continuous cycle of competency and
development". To drive the change and meet the challenges we need bankers
with not only requisite leadership and technical skills but also ethical standards
of the highest order and in this we need look no further than the late Shri
Nani Palkhivala for a role model – a man about whom it can be truly said that
he walked with Kings yet lost not the common touch.